{ "version": "neon-step-sequencer.human-review-packet.v1", "kind": "human_review_packet", "domain": "audio_mix", "status": "candidate_ready_for_listening_review", "evidenceRolePattern": "interaction_snapshots", "proofBoundary": "Objective receipts support or reject candidate change claims; musical taste still requires listening review.", "requestedIntent": "turn the guitar part down a little", "target": { "routeState": { "proofKind": "neon-route-state", "route": "/neon-lab/games/drum-sequencer", "mode": "song", "selectedSong": "Monkberry Moon Delight (Tab)", "selectedPartIndex": 0 }, "selectedSong": { "proofKind": "neon-selected-song", "selectedSong": "Monkberry Moon Delight (Tab)", "partCount": 9, "mixProfile": { "id": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "label": "Monkberry humanized EQ mix", "description": "Humanized imported-tab mix with softer vocal formants, fuller bass harmonics, darker pads, and a deeper shared room/plate space.", "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.51, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 }, "proofWindows": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "bars": 1, "seed": "riddle-sequencer-bed", "requiredActive": [ "bass", "chord", "guitar" ] }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "bars": 3, "seed": "riddle-sequencer-vocal-melody", "requiredActive": [ "rhythmSynth" ] } ], "eqSettings": { "kick": [ 2.2, -0.8, -3.2, -4.5, -5.5, -5, 0.8, 0 ], "snare": [ -6, -2.5, 1.4, -3, -0.6, 1.4, 0.4, -1.8 ], "hat": [ -12, -12, -12, -10, -7, -2.5, -2.2, -1.1 ], "clap": [ -12, -8, -4, -1.5, 0.8, 0, -1, -2 ], "rim": [ -12, -8, -3.5, -1.2, 0, -0.5, -1.2, -2 ], "bass": [ -1.2, 2.8, -1.4, -4.8, -6, -8, -10, -10 ], "chord": [ -8, -2.8, -4.8, -0.8, -1, -2.8, -4.8, -6.5 ], "guitar": [ -8, -4.8, -3.4, -2.2, 1.2, 1.4, 0.2, -1.8 ], "rhythmSynth": [ -10, -6, -3.8, -1.6, 0.8, 1.8, 0, -2.8 ] }, "mixLanes": { "kick": "Sub thump around 60 Hz with most low-mid box removed.", "bass": "Bass foundation around 80-160 Hz with more 120 Hz body for small speakers.", "snare": "Backbeat body near 250 Hz with controlled upper presence.", "hat": "Soft high pulse, trimmed in brittle 4-8 kHz bands.", "chord": "Darker pad bed with more room depth and less plasticky top.", "guitar": "Mid/presence lane around 1-2 kHz, wider than the pad and glued into the shared music bus.", "rhythmSynth": "Vocal melody lane in the upper mids, forward enough to survive the small-speaker monitor without crowding 1 kHz." } } } }, "request": { "strategy": "mix-level-search", "focusTracks": [ "guitar" ], "claimTarget": { "targetTracks": [ "guitar" ], "direction": "down", "magnitude": "subtle", "maxAbsDelta": 0.12, "magnitudeSource": "intent_text", "source": "explicit_args", "boundary": "Requested target, direction, and magnitude constrain objective candidate support; ranking still only orders listening review." }, "maxIterations": 2, "monitorProfile": "smallSpeaker", "restore": true, "applyBest": false, "candidateActionsAreTransient": true, "approval": null }, "recommendation": { "action": "review_before_applying_candidate", "candidate": { "index": 1, "label": "guitar -0.02", "status": "supported", "classification": null, "claim": "Setting guitar level from 0.51 to 0.49 changes rendered guitar metrics while preserving Neon proof invariants.", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.51, "to": 0.49, "delta": -0.02 }, "rankingMetric": 62.7059, "receipts": [ { "name": "mixer_edit_accepted", "ok": true }, { "name": "candidate_track_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true }, { "name": "candidate_direction_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true }, { "name": "candidate_magnitude_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true }, { "name": "contract_mixer_level_reflects_action", "ok": true }, { "name": "rendered_target_metric_changed", "ok": true }, { "name": "required_instruments_preserved", "ok": true }, { "name": "section_energy_floors_preserved", "ok": true }, { "name": "no_clipping", "ok": true }, { "name": "headroom_guardrail_preserved", "ok": true }, { "name": "no_low_level_proof_window", "ok": true } ], "failedReceipts": [], "guardrails": { "mixerEditAccepted": true, "candidateTrackMatchesRequestedIntent": true, "candidateDirectionMatchesRequestedIntent": true, "contractLevelReflected": true, "renderedTargetMoved": true, "requiredInstrumentsPreserved": true, "activeLanesPreserved": true, "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "noClipping": true, "headroomPreserved": true, "noLowLevelProofWindow": true }, "targetMovement": { "track": "guitar", "moved": true, "deltas": { "rms": -0.00145, "peak": -0.0078, "totalEnergy": -0.000017 }, "before": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.0363, "peak": 0.19785, "totalEnergy": 0.000231 }, "after": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.03485, "peak": 0.19005, "totalEnergy": 0.000214 } }, "requestedIntentMatch": { "track": { "requestedTargetTracks": [ "guitar" ], "candidateTrack": "guitar", "source": "explicit_args" }, "direction": { "requestedDirection": "down", "candidateDelta": -0.02, "source": "explicit_args" }, "magnitude": { "requestedMagnitude": "subtle", "maxAbsDelta": 0.12, "candidateDelta": -0.02, "candidateAbsDelta": 0.02, "source": "intent_text" } }, "activeLaneReceipt": { "version": "neon-step-sequencer.active-lane-receipt.v1", "ok": true, "status": "active_lanes_preserved", "windowCount": 2, "requiredWindowCount": 2, "requiredTracks": [ "bass", "chord", "guitar", "rhythmSynth" ], "missingRequiredActiveCount": 0, "missingWindows": [], "windows": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "status": "passed", "ok": true, "requiredActive": [ "bass", "chord", "guitar" ], "activeInstruments": [ "kick", "snare", "hat", "bass", "chord", "guitar" ], "missingRequiredActive": [], "requiredInstrumentStates": [ { "name": "bass", "active": true, "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, { "name": "chord", "active": true, "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, { "name": "guitar", "active": true, "rms": 0.0307, "peak": 0.1722, "totalEnergy": 0.00017 } ] }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "status": "passed", "ok": true, "requiredActive": [ "rhythmSynth" ], "activeInstruments": [ "kick", "snare", "hat", "bass", "chord", "guitar", "rhythmSynth" ], "missingRequiredActive": [], "requiredInstrumentStates": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "active": true, "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } ] } ], "boundary": "Active-lane preservation proves declared required lanes stayed measurable in proof windows; it does not prove subjective mix quality." }, "sectionHeuristicReviewMetric": 0.1102, "sectionEnergyComparison": { "version": "riddle-proof.audio-section-heuristics.v1", "role": "metric_supported_review_order", "sectionCount": 2, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0958, "peak": 0.7432, "totalEnergy": 0.015691, "loudnessStyleLufs": -21.06, "headroomDb": 2.58, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0936, "peak": 0.7384, "totalEnergy": 0.015677, "loudnessStyleLufs": -21.27, "headroomDb": 2.63, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0022, "peak": -0.0048, "totalEnergy": -0.000014, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.21, "headroomDb": 0.05 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.032, "peak": 0.1793, "totalEnergy": 0.000184 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0307, "peak": 0.1722, "totalEnergy": 0.00017 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0013, "peak": -0.0071, "totalEnergy": -0.000014 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "bass", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 } }, { "name": "chord", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } }, { "name": "guitar", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.032, "peak": 0.1793, "totalEnergy": 0.000184 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0307, "peak": 0.1722, "totalEnergy": 0.00017 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.63, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "baseline": { "rms": 0.2875, "peak": 0.7414, "totalEnergy": 0.015654, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.52, "headroomDb": 2.6, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.2869, "peak": 0.7383, "totalEnergy": 0.015633, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.54, "headroomDb": 2.64, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0006, "peak": -0.0031, "totalEnergy": -0.000021, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.02, "headroomDb": 0.04 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0406, "peak": 0.2164, "totalEnergy": 0.000278 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.039, "peak": 0.2079, "totalEnergy": 0.000257 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0016, "peak": -0.0085, "totalEnergy": -0.000021 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.64, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } } ], "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrailsPreserved": true, "violationCount": 0, "averageAbsLoudnessDelta": 0.11, "averageAbsEnergyDelta": 0.000017, "floors": { "requiredRmsFloor": 0.0005, "requiredPeakFloor": 0.001, "requiredTotalEnergyFloor": 0.000001, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5 }, "trackedInstruments": [ "guitar" ], "boundary": "Loudness-style and section-energy metrics rank candidates for review; they do not prove subjective mix quality." }, "summary": { "status": "passed", "windowCount": 2, "findingCount": 0, "mixProfile": { "id": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "label": "Monkberry humanized EQ mix", "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.51, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 } } } }, "reason": "All objective claim receipts passed for this candidate; ranking only orders listening review." }, "supportedCandidates": [ { "index": 1, "label": "guitar -0.02", "status": "supported", "classification": null, "claim": "Setting guitar level from 0.51 to 0.49 changes rendered guitar metrics while preserving Neon proof invariants.", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.51, "to": 0.49, "delta": -0.02 }, "rankingMetric": 62.7059, "receipts": [ { "name": "mixer_edit_accepted", "ok": true }, { "name": "candidate_track_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true }, { "name": "candidate_direction_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true }, { "name": "candidate_magnitude_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true }, { "name": "contract_mixer_level_reflects_action", "ok": true }, { "name": "rendered_target_metric_changed", "ok": true }, { "name": "required_instruments_preserved", "ok": true }, { "name": "section_energy_floors_preserved", "ok": true }, { "name": "no_clipping", "ok": true }, { "name": "headroom_guardrail_preserved", "ok": true }, { "name": "no_low_level_proof_window", "ok": true } ], "failedReceipts": [], "guardrails": { "mixerEditAccepted": true, "candidateTrackMatchesRequestedIntent": true, "candidateDirectionMatchesRequestedIntent": true, "contractLevelReflected": true, "renderedTargetMoved": true, "requiredInstrumentsPreserved": true, "activeLanesPreserved": true, "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "noClipping": true, "headroomPreserved": true, "noLowLevelProofWindow": true }, "targetMovement": { "track": "guitar", "moved": true, "deltas": { "rms": -0.00145, "peak": -0.0078, "totalEnergy": -0.000017 }, "before": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.0363, "peak": 0.19785, "totalEnergy": 0.000231 }, "after": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.03485, "peak": 0.19005, "totalEnergy": 0.000214 } }, "requestedIntentMatch": { "track": { "requestedTargetTracks": [ "guitar" ], "candidateTrack": "guitar", "source": "explicit_args" }, "direction": { "requestedDirection": "down", "candidateDelta": -0.02, "source": "explicit_args" }, "magnitude": { "requestedMagnitude": "subtle", "maxAbsDelta": 0.12, "candidateDelta": -0.02, "candidateAbsDelta": 0.02, "source": "intent_text" } }, "activeLaneReceipt": { "version": "neon-step-sequencer.active-lane-receipt.v1", "ok": true, "status": "active_lanes_preserved", "windowCount": 2, "requiredWindowCount": 2, "requiredTracks": [ "bass", "chord", "guitar", "rhythmSynth" ], "missingRequiredActiveCount": 0, "missingWindows": [], "windows": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "status": "passed", "ok": true, "requiredActive": [ "bass", "chord", "guitar" ], "activeInstruments": [ "kick", "snare", "hat", "bass", "chord", "guitar" ], "missingRequiredActive": [], "requiredInstrumentStates": [ { "name": "bass", "active": true, "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, { "name": "chord", "active": true, "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, { "name": "guitar", "active": true, "rms": 0.0307, "peak": 0.1722, "totalEnergy": 0.00017 } ] }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "status": "passed", "ok": true, "requiredActive": [ "rhythmSynth" ], "activeInstruments": [ "kick", "snare", "hat", "bass", "chord", "guitar", "rhythmSynth" ], "missingRequiredActive": [], "requiredInstrumentStates": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "active": true, "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } ] } ], "boundary": "Active-lane preservation proves declared required lanes stayed measurable in proof windows; it does not prove subjective mix quality." }, "sectionHeuristicReviewMetric": 0.1102, "sectionEnergyComparison": { "version": "riddle-proof.audio-section-heuristics.v1", "role": "metric_supported_review_order", "sectionCount": 2, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0958, "peak": 0.7432, "totalEnergy": 0.015691, "loudnessStyleLufs": -21.06, "headroomDb": 2.58, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0936, "peak": 0.7384, "totalEnergy": 0.015677, "loudnessStyleLufs": -21.27, "headroomDb": 2.63, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0022, "peak": -0.0048, "totalEnergy": -0.000014, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.21, "headroomDb": 0.05 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.032, "peak": 0.1793, "totalEnergy": 0.000184 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0307, "peak": 0.1722, "totalEnergy": 0.00017 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0013, "peak": -0.0071, "totalEnergy": -0.000014 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "bass", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 } }, { "name": "chord", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } }, { "name": "guitar", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.032, "peak": 0.1793, "totalEnergy": 0.000184 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0307, "peak": 0.1722, "totalEnergy": 0.00017 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.63, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "baseline": { "rms": 0.2875, "peak": 0.7414, "totalEnergy": 0.015654, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.52, "headroomDb": 2.6, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.2869, "peak": 0.7383, "totalEnergy": 0.015633, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.54, "headroomDb": 2.64, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0006, "peak": -0.0031, "totalEnergy": -0.000021, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.02, "headroomDb": 0.04 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0406, "peak": 0.2164, "totalEnergy": 0.000278 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.039, "peak": 0.2079, "totalEnergy": 0.000257 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0016, "peak": -0.0085, "totalEnergy": -0.000021 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.64, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } } ], "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrailsPreserved": true, "violationCount": 0, "averageAbsLoudnessDelta": 0.11, "averageAbsEnergyDelta": 0.000017, "floors": { "requiredRmsFloor": 0.0005, "requiredPeakFloor": 0.001, "requiredTotalEnergyFloor": 0.000001, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5 }, "trackedInstruments": [ "guitar" ], "boundary": "Loudness-style and section-energy metrics rank candidates for review; they do not prove subjective mix quality." }, "summary": { "status": "passed", "windowCount": 2, "findingCount": 0, "mixProfile": { "id": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "label": "Monkberry humanized EQ mix", "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.51, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 } } } }, { "index": 2, "label": "guitar -0.035", "status": "supported", "classification": null, "claim": "Setting guitar level from 0.51 to 0.47 changes rendered guitar metrics while preserving Neon proof invariants.", "action": { "type": "set_mixer_level", "track": "guitar", "from": 0.51, "to": 0.475, "delta": -0.035 }, "rankingMetric": 62.9014, "receipts": [ { "name": "mixer_edit_accepted", "ok": true }, { "name": "candidate_track_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true }, { "name": "candidate_direction_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true }, { "name": "candidate_magnitude_matches_requested_intent", "ok": true }, { "name": "contract_mixer_level_reflects_action", "ok": true }, { "name": "rendered_target_metric_changed", "ok": true }, { "name": "required_instruments_preserved", "ok": true }, { "name": "section_energy_floors_preserved", "ok": true }, { "name": "no_clipping", "ok": true }, { "name": "headroom_guardrail_preserved", "ok": true }, { "name": "no_low_level_proof_window", "ok": true } ], "failedReceipts": [], "guardrails": { "mixerEditAccepted": true, "candidateTrackMatchesRequestedIntent": true, "candidateDirectionMatchesRequestedIntent": true, "contractLevelReflected": true, "renderedTargetMoved": true, "requiredInstrumentsPreserved": true, "activeLanesPreserved": true, "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "noClipping": true, "headroomPreserved": true, "noLowLevelProofWindow": true }, "targetMovement": { "track": "guitar", "moved": true, "deltas": { "rms": -0.0025, "peak": -0.01365, "totalEnergy": -0.000031 }, "before": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.0363, "peak": 0.19785, "totalEnergy": 0.000231 }, "after": { "track": "guitar", "sampleCount": 2, "activeCount": 0, "rms": 0.0338, "peak": 0.1842, "totalEnergy": 0.0002 } }, "requestedIntentMatch": { "track": { "requestedTargetTracks": [ "guitar" ], "candidateTrack": "guitar", "source": "explicit_args" }, "direction": { "requestedDirection": "down", "candidateDelta": -0.035, "source": "explicit_args" }, "magnitude": { "requestedMagnitude": "subtle", "maxAbsDelta": 0.12, "candidateDelta": -0.035, "candidateAbsDelta": 0.035, "source": "intent_text" } }, "activeLaneReceipt": { "version": "neon-step-sequencer.active-lane-receipt.v1", "ok": true, "status": "active_lanes_preserved", "windowCount": 2, "requiredWindowCount": 2, "requiredTracks": [ "bass", "chord", "guitar", "rhythmSynth" ], "missingRequiredActiveCount": 0, "missingWindows": [], "windows": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "status": "passed", "ok": true, "requiredActive": [ "bass", "chord", "guitar" ], "activeInstruments": [ "kick", "snare", "hat", "bass", "chord", "guitar" ], "missingRequiredActive": [], "requiredInstrumentStates": [ { "name": "bass", "active": true, "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, { "name": "chord", "active": true, "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, { "name": "guitar", "active": true, "rms": 0.0298, "peak": 0.1669, "totalEnergy": 0.000159 } ] }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "status": "passed", "ok": true, "requiredActive": [ "rhythmSynth" ], "activeInstruments": [ "kick", "snare", "hat", "bass", "chord", "guitar", "rhythmSynth" ], "missingRequiredActive": [], "requiredInstrumentStates": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "active": true, "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } ] } ], "boundary": "Active-lane preservation proves declared required lanes stayed measurable in proof windows; it does not prove subjective mix quality." }, "sectionHeuristicReviewMetric": 0.2003, "sectionEnergyComparison": { "version": "riddle-proof.audio-section-heuristics.v1", "role": "metric_supported_review_order", "sectionCount": 2, "sections": [ { "name": "introBed", "label": "Intro Bed", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0958, "peak": 0.7432, "totalEnergy": 0.015691, "loudnessStyleLufs": -21.06, "headroomDb": 2.58, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0919, "peak": 0.7346, "totalEnergy": 0.015666, "loudnessStyleLufs": -21.42, "headroomDb": 2.68, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0039, "peak": -0.0086, "totalEnergy": -0.000025, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.36, "headroomDb": 0.1 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.032, "peak": 0.1793, "totalEnergy": 0.000184 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0298, "peak": 0.1669, "totalEnergy": 0.000159 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0022, "peak": -0.0124, "totalEnergy": -0.000025 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "bass", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0209, "peak": 0.0838, "totalEnergy": 0.000087 } }, { "name": "chord", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0022, "peak": 0.0079, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 } }, { "name": "guitar", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.032, "peak": 0.1793, "totalEnergy": 0.000184 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0298, "peak": 0.1669, "totalEnergy": 0.000159 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.68, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } }, { "name": "vocalEntry", "label": "Vocal Entry", "baseline": { "rms": 0.2875, "peak": 0.7414, "totalEnergy": 0.015654, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.52, "headroomDb": 2.6, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.2865, "peak": 0.7374, "totalEnergy": 0.015617, "loudnessStyleLufs": -11.55, "headroomDb": 2.65, "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false }, "delta": { "rms": -0.001, "peak": -0.004, "totalEnergy": -0.000037, "loudnessStyleLufs": -0.03, "headroomDb": 0.05 }, "trackedInstruments": [ { "name": "guitar", "baseline": { "rms": 0.0406, "peak": 0.2164, "totalEnergy": 0.000278 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0378, "peak": 0.2015, "totalEnergy": 0.000241 }, "delta": { "rms": -0.0028, "peak": -0.0149, "totalEnergy": -0.000037 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloors": [ { "name": "rhythmSynth", "preserved": true, "floors": { "rms": 0.0005, "peak": 0.001, "totalEnergy": 0.000001 }, "baseline": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 }, "candidate": { "rms": 0.0094, "peak": 0.024, "totalEnergy": 0.000015 } } ], "requiredEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrails": { "clipping": false, "lowLevel": false, "headroomDb": 2.65, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5, "headroomOk": true, "violated": [] } } ], "requiredSectionEnergyFloorsPreserved": true, "guardrailsPreserved": true, "violationCount": 0, "averageAbsLoudnessDelta": 0.2, "averageAbsEnergyDelta": 0.000031, "floors": { "requiredRmsFloor": 0.0005, "requiredPeakFloor": 0.001, "requiredTotalEnergyFloor": 0.000001, "minHeadroomDb": 0.5 }, "trackedInstruments": [ "guitar" ], "boundary": "Loudness-style and section-energy metrics rank candidates for review; they do not prove subjective mix quality." }, "summary": { "status": "passed", "windowCount": 2, "findingCount": 0, "mixProfile": { "id": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "label": "Monkberry humanized EQ mix", "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.51, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 } } } } ], "rejectedCandidates": [], "ranking": { "metric": "guardrail_preserving_section_energy_review_order", "role": "review_order_only", "lowerIsBetter": true, "baselineCandidateRankingMetric": 62.5226, "bestCandidateRankingMetric": 62.7059, "rankingMetricDelta": -0.1833, "sectionHeuristics": { "enabled": true, "role": "metric_supported_review_order", "loudnessStyle": "rms_dbfs_estimate", "trackedInstruments": [ "guitar" ], "boundary": "Section-energy and loudness-style metrics rank candidates for review; they do not prove subjective mix quality." } }, "baseline": { "status": "passed", "windowCount": 2, "findingCount": 0, "mixProfile": { "id": "monkberry-moon-delight-eq-lane-mix-v7", "label": "Monkberry humanized EQ mix", "mixerLevels": { "kick": 0.9, "snare": 0.67, "hat": 0.34, "clap": 0.27, "rim": 0.29, "bass": 0.62, "chord": 0.16, "guitar": 0.51, "rhythmSynth": 0.84 } } }, "guardrails": { "supportedClaimCandidateCount": 2, "rejectedCandidateCount": 0, "stateRestoredAfterLoop": true, "noPermanentEditUnlessApplyBest": true, "approvedCandidateApplied": null }, "listenerPrompts": [ "Does the supported candidate match the requested musical intent?", "Is the changed part better balanced in the proof window?", "Did the proof window contain the musical material being judged?", "Would another section or speaker profile change the listening decision?" ], "caveats": [ "This packet does not prove subjective mix quality.", "A supported candidate proves objective receipts and guardrails only.", "Ranking orders review; it is not a taste score.", "Section-energy and loudness-style metrics are review aids, not proof that a candidate sounds better.", "Keep or apply the candidate only after listening review." ] }